Press "Enter" to skip to content

'This is who we are': The US has a history of putting families in cages, and it didn't start with Trump

'This is who we are': The US has a history of putting families in cages, and it didn't start with Trump

A two-year-old Honduran asylum seeker cries as her mother is searched and detained near the U.S.-Mexico border on June 12, 2018 in McAllen, Texas.

  • President Donald Trump’s practice of separating families that illegally cross the border has spawned widespread outrage and condemnation.
  • But the US wasn’t much better about it under Obama.
  • Obama came up with ways to quickly deport millions of migrants, many of whom allege mistreatment, drugging, and abuse while in US care. 
  • Obama and other top Democrats strongly defended the practice of using harsh treatments at the border to deter migrants, something which Trump’s administration has picked up on.
  • An immigration lawyer says that deterring migrants doesn’t work like this.
  • The lawyer says Obama’s immigration practices were terrible, and Trump only made them worse by briefly separating families. 

President Donald Trump’s practice of separating families that illegally cross the border as a deterrent to other potential border crossers has direct roots in the Obama administration, which said and did many of the same things Trump has been widely condemned for.

While Trump’s administration owns its short-lived policy of separating families at the border, former President Barack Obama earned a nickname among immigration activists as the “deporter in chief” for expelling around 3 million people from the US.

And it wasn’t pretty when Obama did it either

Recent court filings allege that US detention centers drugged without consent and abused migrant children in the US under Obama.

Pictures virally circulating online purporting to show Trump’s deportation jails have actually pictured facilities during the Obama administration. 

“In 2014 [Obama’s] solution to the Central American Refugee crisis was to cage mothers with children in deportation internment camps,” Matthew Kolken, an immigration lawyer on the board of the American Immigration Lawyers Association told Business Insider. 

Fleeing Central America, where murder rates number among the world’s highest, tens of thousands of unaccompanied minors and refugees headed for the US’s southern border in 2014. But when they got there, they found the Obama administration ready to take extraordinary steps to stop them.

Kolken says Obama created something called a “rocket docket” that “fast-tracked the deportation of toddlers and families, oftentimes without lawyers to get around a settlement agreement called the Flores agreement,” which bars the US from holding immigrant children for more than 20 days.

“They basically were torturing people,” Kolken said of the Obama administration. “They were putting them in freezers and holding them there until they could be transferred to an expedited deportation.” Kolken says the detention centers were purposefully put in remote locations to stop immigration lawyers and activists from helping the detained. 

Same logic, different administration


The Democratic party, at its highest levels, endorsed the strategy of using harsh consequences at the border to deter others. Confronted by Andrew R. Free, a US immigration lawyer, about how border detentions might stain his legacy, Obama stressed that it was important to deter and deport border crossers.

“I’ll tell you what we can’t have,” Obama said, according to Free. “It’s these parents sending their kids here on a dangerous journey and putting their lives at risk.”

Asked about migrant children standing trial without a lawyer, a senior Justice Department under Obama argued that toddlers can be taught US immigration law

“We have to send a clear message just because your child gets across the border doesn’t mean your child gets to stay,” Hillary Clinton said in 2014

“Those of us who spoke out were told to sit down and shut up” by Democratic officials, Kolken said of his immigration advocacy during the Obama years. 

Trump’s administration has also talked about deterring potential border crossers, but, according to Kolken, it doesn’t work that way.

To successfully deter migrants, the migrants have to know what consequences await them and decide that those consequences are worse than staying put.

“These individuals are fleeing for their lives,” Kolken said of the migrants. “The last thing they’re concerned about” is US immigration law, he said. 

“I equate it to the horrific images of people jumping out of the Twin Towers to their deaths… Burn to death in Central America or jump to extend their lives by what could be mere seconds,” said Kolken.

From a 7.5 to a 10

Children migrants US-Mexico Border

“Things have gotten worse under Trump, but we’re not talking about zero to 10 we’re talking about 7.5 to 10,” said Kolken. 

Separating families is uniquely horrible, and unique to Trump. By taking children away from their sole caregivers, it costs the US tremendously and traumatizes the child. For all Obama’s detention, deportation, and skirting of due process, the families remained together.

But Trump’s policy has a clear lineage from Obama, who also made a “strategic decision to criminally prosecute individuals” who illegally entered the country, according to Kolken.

Obama left Trump with a backlog of about 600,000 people to deport. When Obama left office, 52% of federal criminal prosecutions were over immigration, according to Syracuse University“Any of those people that end up getting deported should be attributed Obama, not Trump,” said Kolken. 

But today, Trump, not Obama, leads the US, and while the outrage over separating families can be attributed to Trump, the detention of families at the border is a US tradition as of late. 

Senators, pundits, and Americans of all stripes have condemned Trump’s border policy by trying to distance themself with some formulation of: “This is not who we are as a nation.

But according to Kolken, “it is who we are. This is who we’ve been for a long time. We are a nation that has a policy of putting putting babies in jail.”

Now that Trump has signed an executive order to keep families together, his immigration policy is much the same as Obama’s, but for Kolken and other advocates for immigrants, that’s far short of humane. 

SEE ALSO: The feds are moving ahead with private land seizures to make room for Trump’s border wall

Join the conversation about this story »

NOW WATCH: This top economist has a radical plan to change the way Americans vote